Signed Laws and Binding Resolutions for Ballot Questions
Alabama - HB 60, passed House and Senate; enacted without governor's signature, June 9, 2011. Opposes elements of federal health reform, providing by constitutional amendment that residents may provide for their own health care, and that "a law or rule shall not compel any person, employer, or health care provider to participate in any health care system." This amendment required voter approval or disapproval on the November 6, 2012 ballot. "Amendment 6" Passed with 59.0% Yes votes.
Alabama - HB 109, enacted, became law as Act No. 2013-420, May 20, 2013. Establishes the interstate "Health Care Compact" in the state of Alabama, allowing states that join the compact to propose state health policies that could replace federal provisions, citing, "Each member state, within its state, may suspend by legislation the operation of all federal laws, rules, regulations and orders regarding health care that are inconsistent with the laws and regulations adopted by the member state pursuant to this compact." The laws also seeks to use appropriated federal funds, redirected to state-specified programs. The interstate compact plan requires prior approval by the U.S. Congress before it becomes a recognized as interstate compact.
Arkansas - HB 1053, signed into law by the governor as Act No. 276, March 13, 2014. Restricts ACA-related activities by providing that the State Insurance Department shall not allocate, budget, expend, or utilize any appropriation authorized by the General Assembly for the purpose of advertisement, promotion, or other activities designed to promote or encourage enrollment in the Arkansas Health Insurance Marketplace or the Health Care Independence Program, including unsolicited communications mailed to potential recipients; television, radio, or online commercials; billboard or mobile billboard advertising; advertisements printed in newspapers, magazines, or other print media; and Internet websites and electronic media. Also would prohibit responding to an inquiry regarding the coverage for which a potential recipient might be eligible, including without limitation providing educational materials or information regarding any coverage for which the individual might qualify. Also see S 111.
Arkansas - SB 111, signed into law by the governor as Act No. 257, March 7, 2014. Provides that the Dept. of Human Services, Div. of Medical Services shall not allocate, budget, expend, or utilize any appropriation authorized by the General Assembly for the purpose of advertisement, promotion, or other activities designed to promote or encourage enrollment in the Arkansas Health Insurance Marketplace or the Health Care Independence Program, including without limitation, unsolicited communications mailed to potential recipients; television, radio, or online commercials. Also see H 1053.
Florida - H 1193, passed House and Senate; signed by the governor as Chapter No. 2011-126, June 2, 2011. By state statute, prohibits a person from being compelled to purchase health insurance except under specified conditions including dangerous occupation, voluntary enrollment in public benefits or contracts between private parties.
Florida - S 2, passed Senate and House; sent to the secretary of state, 5/4/2011. Joint resolution proposes a State Constitutional amendment to prohibit laws or rules from compelling any person, employer, or health care provider to participate in any health care system, permit any person or employer to purchase lawful health care services directly from health care provider, or permit health care provider to accept direct payment from person or employer for lawful health care services. This amendment required voter approval or disapproval on the November 6, 2012 ballot. "Amendment 1" Failed, with 48.5% Yes votes.
Georgia - H 461, passed House and Senate; signed by the governor as Act 10, April 20, 2011. Adopts the interstate Health Care Compact; provides for member state control over personal health care decisions; vests regulatory authority to the states; provides that member states resolve by the adoption into law provisions of the Health Care Compact to define health care as including an individual or group plan that provides or pays the cost of health care, services, or supplies; provides for the right to federal monies.
Georgia - H 943, H 990 both passed House and Senate as amended (from H 707); signed by the governor, April 15, 2014. Prohibits any agency or state action to expand Medicaid or accept any federal grant money to establish a state-run health exchange. Also ends the Univ. of Georgia Health Navigator Program. Titled "Georgia Health Freedom Law;" goes into effect July 1.
Indiana - S 461, passed Senate and House; signed by the governor as Public Law No. 160-2011, May 12, 2011. Provides by statute that "a resident of Indiana may not be required to purchase coverage under a health plan. A resident may delegate to the resident's employer the resident's authority to purchase or decline to purchase coverage under a health plan." Also authorizes consumer protections, rate review and rescissions compatible with the ACA. Note: Other provisions restricting agencies from implementing ACA provisions were deleted from the final enacted bill.
Indiana - H 1269 of 2012; signed by the governor as Chapter 150 of 2012 on March 19, 2012. Authorizes the state to join the "Health Care Compact," requiring member states of the compact to take action to secure the consent of Congress for the compact; asserting that member states of the compact have the primary responsibility to regulate health care in their respective States. Also seeks to establish that “Each member state, for the member state's jurisdiction, may, to the extent allowed under the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the member state, suspend by legislation federal laws, regulations, and orders concerning health care that are inconsistent with the laws and regulations adopted by the member state under the compact.” Also creates the Interstate Advisory Health Care Commission and would assert the rights of member states to certain federal health money.
Kansas - H 2182, passed House and Senate; signed by the governor, May 25, 2011. Opposes specific provisions of federal health reform, providing (in Sec. 7) by state statute that "The government shall not interfere with a resident's right to purchase or refuse to purchase health insurance." Also provides that residents, employers and health providers "shall not be required to pay penalties or fines" for direct payment without using health insurance; the "government shall not enact a law" that "would impose a form of punishment for exercising these rights." Effective date is July 1, 2011.
Kansas - H 2553 of 2014, passed House and Senate; signed by the governor, April 22, 2014. Accepts and adopts membership in the Health Care Compact; provides that each member state, within its state, may suspend by legislation the operation of all federal laws, rules, and regulations, and orders regarding health care that are inconsistent with the laws and regulations adopted by the member state pursuant to the compact.
Kentucky - H 265 passed House and Senate, signed by the governor, April 11, 2012. 2012-14 Appropriations act section 10, authorizes the state to "to explore the feasibility of an Interstate Reciprocal Health Benefit Plan Compact (IRHBPC) with contiguous states" to allow Kentucky and residents of contiguous states to purchase health benefit plan coverage among the states participating with the compact. The purposes of this compact are, through means of joint and cooperative action among the compacting states to promote and protect the interest of consumers purchasing health benefit plan coverage. (Note: this law is not a challenge to the provisions of PPACA; it is included as an alternative approach, for comparative information purposes.)
Missouri - H 45, passed House and Senate; signed by the governor, 7/8/2011. Provides that "any federal mandate implemented by the state shall be subject to statutory authorization of the general assembly." Creates a new $20,000 employer tax deduction for each new full-time job created with an annual salary of at least the average annual county wage if the small business also offers new employee health insurance and pays at least 50% of the health insurance premiums of all full-time employees who opt into the offered plan. Any new proposed rule must "Certify that the rule does not have an adverse impact on, or must exempt small businesses with fewer than fifty full- or part-time employees."
Missouri - H 423, passed House and Senate; became law without governor's signature, 7/14/2011. Establishes the interstate Health Care Compact, which would pledge member states to act jointly to oppose certain elements within health reform.
Missouri - S 464, passed Senate and House, sent to Secretary of State, 5/31/2012; governor's signature not required. Would amend state law chapter 376, a new section relating to the authority for creating and operating health insurance exchanges in Missouri. Would prohibit the establishment and operation of health insurance exchanges in Missouri unless the exchange is created by a legislative act, an initiative petition, or referendum, requiring voter approval. S 464, as Proposition E, was on the statewide ballot November 6, 2012 for a binding vote. "Proposition E" Passed with 61.8% Yes votes.
Montana - S 125, passed Senate and House; governor's amendments rejected; signed by the governor as Chapter 402, May 13, 2011. Opposes elements of federal health reform, providing that by state law state agencies "may not implement or enforce in any way the provisions" or any federal regulation or policy implementing federal health reform "that relates to the requirement for individuals to purchase health insurance and maintain minimum essential health insurance coverage." Bars public employers or state employees from implementing or enforcing participation in the individual mandate to purchase health insurance.
Montana - S 418, passed House and Senate; enacted as Chapter 310 and sent to the Secretary of State, May 4, 2011. Would prohibit, by state statute, the federal and state government from mandating the purchase of health insurance coverage; would prohibit imposing penalties related to health insurance decisions. The act will be submitted by referendum to voters for approval or disapproval in the November 2012 state election.
New Hampshire - S 148, passed Senate and House; became law as Chapter 266 without governor's signature, 7/14/2011. Provides by insurance statute that a resident of New Hampshire shall not be required to obtain, to maintain, or be assessed a fee or fine for failure to obtain health insurance coverage. Effective date July 1, 2011.
New Hampshire - H 601, Passed House and Senate; became law as Chapter 264 without governor's signature, 7/14/2011. By statute, requires that before establishing standards for enforcing the provisions of the federal Affordable Care Act, the insurance commissioner shall obtain approval from a newly created N.H. legislative Health Insurance Reform Oversight Committee. The provision applies "to any state official or agency that seeks to enforce the insurance provisions of the Act" and includes enforcing the immediate "consumer protections and market reforms." Effective date July 1, 2011.
New Hampshire - S 1297, passed Senate and House, signed by the governor as Chapter No. 2012-231, June 18, 2012. Prohibits the state from establishing a state based health insurance exchange. Also provides that in the event a federally-facilitated exchange is established for New Hampshire, the insurance commissioner retains authority with respect to insurance products sold in New Hampshire "on the federally-facilitated exchange to the maximum extent possible by law." Also required the state attorney general to join the lawsuit challenging the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act and require federal grant moneys received by the state for implementation of the PPACA to be returned to the federal government. Effective date June 18, 2012.
North Carolina - S 4 was enacted as Act No. 2013-5, March 6, 2013. By state law, it specifies the state's intent not to operate a state-run or "partnership" health benefit exchange, providing that future Medicaid eligibility determinations would be made by the state rather than the federally facilitated exchange, also rejects the Affordable Care Act's optional Medicaid expansion. It does permit use of federal grants for premium rate review.
North Dakota - H 1165 was enacted and signed by the governor, April 4, 2011; providing by state law that a resident is not required to have a policy of individual health coverage, and would not be "liable for any penalty, assessment, fee, or fine." Applies regardless of whether the resident has or is eligible for health insurance coverage under a policy, through an employer or under a plan administered by the state or federal government. Continues an exception if health coverage is required by a court or by the state Department of Human Services through a court or administrative proceeding.
North Dakota - S 2309 was enacted and signed by the governor, April 27, 2011. [Full text] Using parts of model language invoking "nullification," establishes by statute that, "The legislative assembly declares that the federal laws known as (PPACA) likely are not authorized by the United States Constitution and may violate its true meaning and intent as given by the founders and ratifiers." ... no provision "may interfere with an individual’s choice of a medical or insurance provider except as otherwise provided by the laws of this state."
Ohio - Issue #3, a citizen-initiated constitutional amendment was approved by voters on the November 8, 2011 ballot. It seeks to preserve their "freedom to choose their health care and health care coverage." It passed 66 percent Yes to 34 percent No. Similar pending Ohio legislation was not enacted in 2011-2012 (as of 8/10/12).
Oklahoma - S 722 was enacted and signed by the governor, May 18, 2011. Adopts the interstate Health Care Compact; provides for member state control over personal health care decisions; vests regulatory authority to the states; provides that member states resolve by the adoption into law provisions of the Health Care Compact to define health care as including an individual or group plan that provides or pays the cost of health care, services, or supplies.
South Carolina - H 3700 State budget for fiscal year 2011-12 was enacted and signed by the governor, August 2, 2011. It includes Section 89.126, that provides that "If federal law permits, the State of South Carolina opts out of "certain provisions in the Affordable Care Act, including the individual mandate or minimum coverage requirement, the employer contribution requirement, and insurance expansions including coverage for adult dependents up to age 26.
South Carolina - S 836, passed Senate and House, signed by the governor as Act 221, 6/21/2012. Enacts state participation in the Interstate Healthcare Compact; providing that state compact members must take action to obtain congressional consent to the compact; providing that the legislature is vested with the responsibility to regulate healthcare delivered in their state; provides for healthcare funding; also establishes the S.C. interstate advisory Health Care Commission.
Tennessee - S 79 was enacted and signed by the governor as Chapter 9, March 18, 2011. A statute declaring it state public policy that every person within the state "shall be free to choose or to decline to choose any mode of securing health care services without penalty or threat of penalty;" it requires that no state or local public official, employee, or agent "shall act to impose, collect, enforce, or effectuate any penalty in this state."
Tennessee - H 937, enacted and signed by the governor, 4/14/2014. Prohibits, by statute, the state, the TennCare or Medicaid program or its residents from participating in any state option for Medicaid eligibility expansion authorized under the federal PPACA.
Texas - SB 7, passed Senate, passed House, 96y-48n, 6/27/2011; signed by the governor, July 19, 2011. State market reform act; includes an interstate health care compact, allowing Texas to partner with other states to ask the federal government for control — both fiscal and governmental — over Medicare, Medicaid and commercial coverage; also directs state officials to seek a waiver from Washington to operate Medicaid with a federal block grant.
Utah - H 175 and S 208 of 2012 - Passed House and Senate; signed by the governor, 3/19/2012. Provides by statute that the state join an interstate Health Care Compact, including a pledge to take joint and separate action to secure congressional approval "in order to return the authority to regulate health care to the member states." Would seek to authorize that "Each member state, within its state, may suspend by legislation the operation of all federal laws, rules, regulations, and orders regarding health care that are inconsistent with the laws and regulations adopted by the member state pursuant to this compact."
Utah - H 131 of 2013 - signed by the governor as Chapter 101, 3/26/13. Renames the Constitutional Defense Council and creates the Commission on Federalism; provides for the repeal of the State Health Compact by July 1, 2014, and subjects these provisions to a 10-point sunset review prior to repeal.
Virginia - SB 283 passed Senate and House and became law as Chapter 106 of 2010 on March 10, 2010 becoming the first such statute in the nation. Amends state law by adding a section, "Health insurance coverage not required. No resident of this Commonwealth, regardless of whether he has or is eligible for health insurance coverage under any policy or program provided by or through his employer, or a plan sponsored by the Commonwealth or the federal government, shall be required to obtain or maintain a policy of individual insurance coverage. No provision of this title shall render a resident of this Commonwealth liable for any penalty, assessment, fee, or fine as a result of his failure to procure or obtain health insurance coverage." It does not apply to Medicaid and CHIP coverage.
Wyoming - SJR 2, approved by both House and Senate by a 2/3rds vote; governor's signature not required. A proposed constitutional amendment, states that residents have the right to make their own health care decisions, while "any person may pay, and a health care provider may accept, direct payment for health care without imposition of penalties or fines for doing so." Also provides that the state "shall act to preserve these rights from undue governmental infringement." Scheduled to appear on the November 6, 2012 ballot for voter approval or disapproval by majority vote.
Wyoming - S 58 of 2012 - Enacted by Senate and House; signed by the governor as Chapter 61, 3/9/2011. Amends the duties of the Wyoming Health Insurance Exchange Steering Committee to require a study report with 3 options including 1) an exchange based on Wyoming data without influence from the health care reform acts, 2) using selected parts of required federal features and 3) an exchange in complete compliance with the Act. The statute limits the state's authority to operate a federally required health insurance exchange, restating that "No state agency or any person representing the state of Wyoming shall, prior to April 1, 2013, commit the state" to operating an exchange.
Non-Binding Resolutions, Adopted 2011-2012
Colorado - HR 11-1010, Adopted non-binding House-only resolution, citing the 10th Amendment, requests the U.S. Congress to repeal the individual mandate required by PPACA; also strongly encourages Congress to "recognize individual states' efforts to reform health care by grandfathering any state laws, regulations, or practices intended to contain costs, improve quality, increase consumerism, or otherwise implement health system reform concepts."
Colorado - HR 12-1003 of 2012, Adopted non-binding House-only resolution, requesting the U.S. Congress to call a constitutional convention to propose an amendment to repeal the Affordable Care Act. Article 5 requires two-thirds of the legislatures to make such a formal request in order to convene a constitutional convention.
> Article: Colorado House Seeks U.S. Convention to Repeal ACA.
Missouri - SR 27, Adopted non-binding Senate-only resolution calls on the state Attorney General to file an independent lawsuit or join 20 state attorneys general in their lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of the federal health care reform legislation, including to "aggressively defend the validity of Proposition C as voted on by the people of Missouri in the 2010 Missouri General Election."
New Hampshire - SR 9, Adopted Senate-only resolution, requests an opinion of the state Supreme Court justices concerning the constitutionality of H 89, a legislative measure requiring the attorney general to join the lawsuit challenging the Affordable Care Act.
North Dakota - HCR 3016, Adopted non-binding concurrent resolution, urges the U.S. Congress to repeal the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act. Adopted by the House and Senate, April 18, 2011.
South Dakota - HCR 1004, Adopted non-binding resolution, opposes elements of the Affordable Care Act, declaring that the "Legislature finds that in the absence of such specific (constitutional) authority," and in conjunction with "powers retained by the people and the states pursuant to the ninth and tenth amendments, all such federal legislation is inherently unconstitutional. Adopted by House 42y-26n; adopted by Senate 28y-5n.
Passed but Vetoed by Governors
Arizona - S 1088, passed House and Senate; vetoed by governor, May 28, 2011. Would oppose any state role in compulsory participation in a health care system or purchase of health insurance; would prohibit any government official from enforcing prohibitions on purchase or sale of health insurance in private health care systems otherwise authorized by the laws of the state; would affirm a right to direct payment or purchase of lawful health care services; would prohibit threats of penalties, fines, taxes, salaries, wage withholding, surcharges or fees to punish or discourage the exercise of such right. Also would establish an Interstate Health Freedom Compact, to unify states opposing the ACA.
Arizona - S 1592, passed Senate and House; vetoed by governor, 4/18/2011. Would authorize the Governor to enter into the "Interstate Health Care Freedom Compact," intended to guarantee the right and freedom of residents to pay or not to pay directly for health care services and to participate or not to participate in health plans and health systems. Compacts would coordinate across state lines to enforce "health care freedom criminal laws" which seek to make it a crime to interfere with residents' health services, specified above. Also would create an "Interstate Advisory Health Care Commission" with representatives from each member state. [See Governor Brewer's veto message, citing state separation of powers and added fiscal burden.]
Idaho - H 298, passed House and Senate; vetoed by governor, 4/20/2011. Would have provided that no person within the State shall be compelled to participate in a government health insurance program not authorized by the State; provides that the Affordable Care Act shall not be enforced, administered or enacted by the State and no department, agency or political subdivision shall accept or expend moneys related to the implementation of discretionary provisions of the Act, such as exchanges and insurance consumer protections. [See Governor Otter’s executive order of April 20, which includes similar restrictions on the state accepting funds or involvement.]
Minnesota - S 760, passed Senate and House; vetoed by governor, May 24, 2011. Would have opposed selected provisions of the ACA, by declaring that the public policy of the state "is that every person within the state of Minnesota is and shall be free to choose or decline to choose any mode of securing health care services without penalty or threat of penalty." Also would provide that no state official or employee "shall act to impose, collect, enforce, or effectuate any penalty" related to ACA mandates for coverage.
Montana - H 526, passed Senate and House; vetoed by governor, 5/12/2011. Would provide for an "Interstate Health Care Freedom Compact;" intended to guarantee the right and freedom of residents to pay or not to pay directly for health care services and to participate or not to participate in health plans and health systems. Compacts would coordinate across state lines. Would create advisory representatives from each state and require congressional approval.
Montana - S 224, passed Senate and House; vetoed by governor, 4/21/2011. Would require legislative approval for any grant application, expenditure or implementation of the federal Affordable Care Act.
Montana - S 228, passed Senate and House; vetoed by governor, 4/13/2011. Would prohibit the creation of a state-based health insurance exchange.
North Carolina - H 2, passed House and Senate; vetoed by governor, 3/5/2011; veto override failed in House 3/9/2011. Would oppose elements of federal health reform, providing by state law that "no law or rule shall compel a person" to provide for health care services or medical treatment for that person or contract with, or enroll in, a public or private health care system or health insurance plan as a condition of receiving state economic aid.
Texas - H 335, passed House and Senate; sent to the governor, 5/30/2011; vetoed by governor 6/17/2011. Would provide that a state agency may not implement requirements for mandated provisions of federal health care reform laws unless the agency submits a report of expenses incurred. Relates to required purchase of health insurance by a person or employer, penalties imposed for failure of employers to provide such insurance, expanded eligibility for the state Medicaid program or state child health plan program, mandates and new health insurance programs.