Skip to Page Content
Home  |  Contact Us  |  Press Room  |  Site Overview  |  Help  |  Login  |  Register
Add to MyNCSL

Pharmacist Conscience Clauses: Laws and Legislation

Updated November 2007

Health provider “refusal clauses” (also known as "conscience clauses") were first enacted in response to the United States Supreme Court's decision in the Roe v. Wade case, 410 U.S. 113 (1973).  Roe v. Wade was the landmark decision establishing that most laws against abortion violate a constitutional righy to privacy, overturning all state laws outlawing or restricting abortion.  Some states have subsequently proposed legislation and passed laws designed to allow doctors and other direct providers of health care to refuse to perform or assist in an abortion, and hospitals to refuse to allow abortion on their premises.  Now, the issue is expanding as pharmacists are refusing to fill emergency contraception and contraception prescriptions. This movement resulted in the term “conscience clause," which gives pharmacists the right to refuse to perform certain services based on a violation of personal beliefs or values. Most of the debate revolves around a pharmacist dispensing emergency contraception. Emergency contraception is used to prevent a pregnancy, not terminate a pregnancy, and is a general term used to describe several different types of birth control pills that are used in increased doses within 72 hours of unprotected intercourse.  Emergency contraception is not the same thing as Mifeprex, which is the brand name of mifepristone in the United States and is sometimes referred to as non-surgical abortion, medical abortion, or RU-486.  Pharmacists do not play a role in administering these medications.  

In some states, legislators are introducing bills that would explicitly grant pharmacists the right to refuse to dispense drugs related to contraception on moral grounds. Other state legislators are introducing legislation that would require pharmacies to fill any legal prescription for birth control, much like Governor Blagojevich's emergency rule in Illinois, which requires pharmacies to provide the morning after pill.

Four States (Arkansas, Georgia, Mississippi, and South Dakota) have passed laws allowing a pharmacist to refuse to dispense emergency contraception drugs. Illinois passed an emergency rule that requires a pharmacist to dispense FDA approved contraception. Colorado, Florida, Maine and Tennesee have broad refusal clauses that do not specifically mention pharmacists.

California pharmacists have a duty to dispense prescriptions and can only refuse to dispense a prescription, including contraceptives, when their employer approves the refusal and the woman can still access her prescription in a timely manner.

New Jersey's new law (effective November 2007), prohibits pharmacists for refusing to fill prescriptions solely on moral, religious or ethical grounds. (see 2007 legislative chart).

Conscience Clause Laws (allowing the refusal to fill)

Arkansas § 20-9-1001 allows certain individuals or entities to refuse to perform abortion services and provide or dispense contraceptives in all or most circumstances.

California SB 644 Chapter No. 417 prohibits a health care licentiate from obstructing a patient in obtaining a prescription drug or device and would require the licentiate to dispense drugs and devices pursuant to a lawful prescription or order except in specified circumstances, including on ethical, moral, or religious grounds asserted by the licentiate.

Colorado Rev. Stat. 25-6-102 states that no private institution, it employees, or physicians may be held liable for refusing to dispense contraceptive supplies, procedures or information if their refusal is based on a moral or religious objection to such activities.

Florida 2003 Stat. XXIX 381.0051 states that physicians or other people may not be held liable for refusing to dispense contraceptive or family planning devices, services or information.

Georgia Admin. Code § 480-5-.03 provides that a pharmacist shall not be required to fill a prescription for an emergency contraceptive drug; provides that such refusal shall not be the basis for any claim for damages; provides for the duration of the effectiveness of the written objection; provides for related matters; repeals conflicting laws.

Illinois requires pharmacies to dispense contraception. Gov. Rod Blagojevich (D) issued emergency rules that require pharmacies in the state to dispense FDA-approved contraceptives. If the pharmacy does not have the drug or a suitable substitute in stock, then the pharmacy must order the medication through standard procedures, transfer the prescription to another local pharmacy or return the prescription to the patient. The emergency rules will be in effect only for 150 days, after which the state is expected to begin the normal rulemaking process in order to make the requirement rule permanent.

Maine Rev. Stat. tit. 22, 1903 (1973) gives physicians and agents of medical and related facilities the right to refuse to provide family planning services when such actions would interfere with moral or religious beliefs. 

Mississippi Code Ann. § 41-41-215 permits health care providers, including pharmacists or other pharmacy employees, counselors, social workers, health insures and health care facilities to refuse to provide [any] medical services, including counseling and referral, on religious or ethical grounds (SB 2619).

South Dakota Codified Laws § 36-11-70  allows pharmacists the right to refuse to provide services.

Tennessee Code Ann. 68-34-104 allows physicians or any agent of such an entity to refuse to offer contraceptive services, supplies, or information if it interferes with a moral or religious belief.  States that physicians or other agents may not be held liable for this refusal.

On June 1, 2006 the Washington Board of Pharmacy approved proposed rule language regarding a pharmacist’s responsibilities in dispensing a lawful prescription.  This language would amend Washington Admin. Code 246-863-095 to prohibit a pharmacist from delegating the decision not to dispense prescriptions for any reason.


2007 Legislation (as of March 6, 2007)

PHARMACIST REFUSAL CLAUSES and REQUIRE TO FILLNew item

AZ
SB 1470
Sen. Aboud
Would allow a pharmacist to refuse to dispense a prescription for a contraceptive if the pharmacist has previously notified the pharmacy in writing of the drug or class of drugs to which the pharmacist objects and another pharmacist in the same pharmacy dispenses the prescription without delay.
(Filed and referred to committee 1/29/07)
MO
HB 434
Rep. Stevenson
Would establish the Health Care Rights of Conscience Act to protect the religious, moral, or ethical principles held by a health care provider, health care institution, or health care payer.  Under this bill, the definition of "health care provider" includes pharmacists.
(Filed and referred to committee 1/17/07)
MO
SB 285
Sen. Crowell
Would protect the conscience rights of pharmaceutical professionals, where they would not be required to perform, assist, recommend, refer for, or participate in any service involving a particular drug or device that they have a good faith belief is used for abortions.
(Filed and referred to committee 1/16/07)
NC
HB 155
Rep. Hilton
Would allow a pharmacist to refuse to prescribe or dispense drugs or devices, based on a moral, ethical or religious objection, that would result in an abortion.
(Filed and referred to committee 2/12/07)
NJ
A 2016
Rep. Kean
Would permit health care professionals to refuse to perform or assist in health care services that violate their religious, moral, or ethical convictions.
(Filed and referred to committee 1/10/06; carried over to 2007 session)
NJ
AB 992
Rep. Stender
S 1195
Sen. Madden New item
Would prohibit pharmacists from refusing to dispense medication solely for philosophical, moral or religious reasons.
(AB 992 filed and referred to committee 1/10/06; added as a substitute to S 1195 10/19/06)
(S 1195 filed and referred to committee 1/30/06; passed Senate 31y-6n, 6/26/06; to Assembly 2nd reading 10/19/06)
(S 1195 passed Assembly 6/11/07; Approved P.L.2007, c.199 11/2/07)
NY
S 2317
Sen. Duane
Would establish duties for pharmacies when pharmacists employed by such pharmacy refuse to fill prescriptions on the basis of personal beliefs.
(Filed and referred to committee 2/2/07)
NY
S 2344
Sen. Schneiderman
Would prohibit pharmacists from refusing to dispense medication solely for philosophical, moral, or religious reasons.
(Filed and referred to committee 2/2/07)
RI
HB 5274
Rep. Brien
SB 452
Sen. Goodwin

Would provide protection from discrimination to all health care providers who chose not to participate in a health care service that violates the conscience of the health care provider.  Under this bill, the definition of "health care provider" includes pharmacists.
(H 5274 filed and referred to committee 2/1/07: S 452 filed and referred to committee 2/13/07)

SC
HB 3283
Rep. Davenport
Would enact the Health Care Freedom of Conscience Act, which would prohibit all forms of discrimination, disqualification, coercion, disability, or liability upon such health care providers, institutions, and payers that decline to perform any health care service that violates their conscience.  Under this bill, the definition of "health care provider" includes pharmacists.
(Filed and referred to committee 1/17/07)
SC
SB 126
Sen. Bryant
Would allow a pharmacist to refuse to fill prescriptions for a drug, class of drugs, or device on ethical, moral, or religious grounds if the pharmacist has previously notified his employer, in writing, of the drug, class of drugs, or device to which he objects.
(Filed and referred to committee 1/9/07)
TX
HB 1996
Rep.

Gonzalez Toureilles

Would allow a pharmacist to refuse, for moral or ethical reasons, to dispense a prescription drug if the pharmacist follows the policies and procedures established by the pharmacy in which the pharmacist practices to ensure a patient has reasonable access to a valid prescription at that pharmacy or another pharmacy.
(Filed and referred to committee 2/26/07)

VT
HB 315
Rep. Donahue

Would seek to respect and protect the fundamental rights of conscience of all individuals who provide health care services by allowing a health care provider (includes pharmacists) to not participate in a health care service that violates his or her conscience.
(Filed and referred to committee 2/15/07)

WV
HB 2092
Rep. Schoen
Would allow pharmacists and other individuals involved in dispensing medicines to refuse to fill prescriptions or dispense any substance that can be used as part of an abortion-related procedure.
(Filed and referred to committee 1/12/07)
WV
HB 2416
Rep. Hatfield
Would prohibit pharmacists and other persons involved in dispensing medicines from refusing to fill prescriptions.
Filed and referred to committee 1/23/07)
WV
SB 743
Sen. Sypolt
Would allow pharmacists to refuse to fill prescriptions used as abortion-related procedure.
(Filed and referred to committee 2/19/07)

 

2006 Legislation

PHARMACIST REFUSAL CLAUSES

AL
HB 609
Rep. McClurkin

Would give health care providers, health care institutions, and health care payers the authority to refuse to perform or to participate in health care services that violate their conscience and would provide immunity from discrimination based on and liability for such refusal.  Although a general refusal clause, the bill defines "health care provider" to include pharmacists.
(Filed and referred to committee 2/9/06; did not pass by end of 2006 regular session)

CA
AB 2583New item
Rep. Nation
Would require the State Board of Pharmacy to create and provide a sign informing a patient of his or her right to timely access to a prescribed drug or device that a licensed pharmacist has refused to dispense based on ethical, moral, or religious grounds.  The bill would require pharmacists authorized to make such a refusal, or their employers, to visibly place the sign at or near the entrance of the business.
(Filed and referred to committee 2/24/06; passed House 47y-31n, 5/25/06; passed Senate 24y-15n, 8/17/06; signed into law by governor as Ch. 487, 9/26/06)

GA
HB 566
Rep. Loudermilk 

Would allow any employee of the agencies engaged in the administration of this chapter to refuse to accept the duty of offering family-planning services to the extent that such duty is contrary to such employee´s personal religious beliefs; would provide that such refusal not be grounds for any disciplinary action, for dismissal, for any interdepartmental transfer, for any other discrimination in employment, for suspension from employment, or for any loss in pay or other benefits.  Would authorize the directors or supervisors of such agencies to reassign the duties of any such employees in order to carry out this chapter effectively.  Would only apply to state employees.
(Filed and referred to committee 2/18/05; carried over from 2005 regular session; did not pass by end of 2006 regular session)

GA
SB 123
Sen. Whitehead

Would allow a pharmacist who states in writing an objection to any abortion to be exempt from filling a prescription for a drug if the pharmacist believes the drug would have the effect or possible effect of terminating a pregnancy.
(Filed and referred to committee 2/7/05; passed Senate 3/2/06; did not pass House by end of 2006 regular session)

IL
HB 4230
Rep. Granberg
Would amend the Pharmacy Practice Act of 1987.  Would provide that a pharmacist licensed under the Act may, based on his or her personal religious beliefs, refuse to fill a prescription for and to dispense emergency contraception.
(Filed and referred to committee 12/5/05; re-referred to committee 1/4/06)

IL
HB 4246
Rep. Stephens

Would amend the Pharmacy Practice Act of 1987.  Would provide that a pharmacist licensed under the Act may, based on his or her personal religious beliefs, refuse to fill a prescription for and to dispense emergency contraception.
(Filed and referred to committee 12/12/05; re-referred to committee 1/4/06)

IL
HB 4346
Rep. Granberg

Would amend the Pharmacy Practice Act of 1987.  Would provide that a pharmacist licensed under the Act may, based on his or her personal religious beliefes, refuse to fill a prescription for and to dispense emergency contraception.
(Filed and referred to committee 1/3/06; first reading and referred to committee 1/4/06; reassigned to committee 3/3/06)

IL
HB 4786
Rep. Stephens
Would amend the Pharmacy Practice Act of 1987 to provide that a pharmacist licensed under the Act may, based on his or her personal religious beliefs, refuse to fill a prescription for and to dispense emergency contraception.  Amends the Health Care Right of Conscience Act to add the dispensation of prescribed medication to the list of activities included in the definition of "health care", adds pharmacist to the list of occupations included in the definition of "health care personnel", and adds pharmacy to the list of facilities included in the definition of "health care facility".
(Filed and referred to committee 1/18/06)

IL
SB 2343
Sen. Brady

Would amend the Pharmacy Practice Act of 1987 to provide that a pharmacist licensed under the Act may, based on his or her personal religious beliefs, refuse to fill a prescription for and to dispense emergency contraception.  Amends the Health Care Right of Conscience Act to add the dispensation of prescribed medication to the list of activities included in the definition of "health care", adds pharmacist to the list of occupations included in the definition of "health care personnel", and adds pharmacy to the list of facilities included in the definition of "health care facility".
(Filed and referred to committee 1/12/06)
IN
SB 4
Sen. Drozda
Would provide that a person may not be required, as a condition of training, employment, pay, promotion, or privileges, to dispense a medical device or drug that may result in an abortion or a birth control device or medication.
(Filed and referred to committee 1/9/06; did not pass by end of 2006 regular session)

MI
HB 4741
Rep. Palmer
SB 938
Sen. George

Would provide standards for personnel policies to protect and accommodate the right of conscience of health care providers who conscientiously object to providing or participating in certain health care services under certain circumstances; would provide for protection from certain liability; would provide for penalties and remedies.
(HB 4741 filed and referred to committee 5/5/05; SB 938 filed and referred to committee 12/13/05; carried over from 2005 regular session)

MI
HB 5978
Rep. Gonzales

Would prohibit a pharmacist from refusing to dispense or transfer a prescription based solely on his or her ethical, moral, or religious beliefs.
(Filed and referred to committee 4/25/06)

MN
HF 2597
Rep. Emmer
SF 2430
Sen. Wergin

Would authorize pharmacists to refuse to dispense medication that they find morally objectionable.
(Filed and referred to committee 3/1/06; did not pass by end of 2006 regular session)

MN
HF 3032
Rep. Emmer
SF 2647
Sen. Kiscaden

Would prohibit pharmacists from refusing to dispense a prescription drug or device except under certain circumstances.
(Filed and referred to committee 3/1/06; did not pass by end of 2006 regular session)

MN
HF 3104
Rep. Goodwin
SF 3277
Sen. Lourey
Would require the Board of Pharmacy to investigate and take appropriate discipline against a registered pharmacy if pharmacy employees fail to compound or dispense a drug that is medically appropriate for the patient for which it was prescribed, and the patient is denied a drug that may reasonably be expected to be compounded or dispensed in pharmacies by pharmacists.
(Filed and referred to committee 3/2/06; did not pass by end of 2006 regular session)
MN
HF 3560
Rep. Goodwin
SF 3242
Sen. Lourey
Would prohibit pharmacists from refusing to dispense a prescription drug or device except under certain circumstances.
(Filed and referred to committee 3/15/06; did not pass by end of 2006 regular session)
MO
HB 1539
Rep. Stevenson
Would establish the Health Care Rights of Conscience Act to protect the religious, moral, or ethical principles held by a health care provider, health care institution, or health care payer.  Specifies that a health care provider is not required to participate in a health care service that violates his or her conscience and will not be held liable for or descriminated against for refusing to provide a health care service.  Although a general refusal clause, the bill defines "health care provider" to include pharmacists.
(Filed and referred to committee 2/2/06; favorable committee report 3/8/06; did not pass by end of 2006 regular session)
MO
SB 609
Sen. Crowell

Would protect the conscience rights of pharmaceutical professionals, who shall not be required to perform, assist, recommend, refer for, or participate in any service involving a particular drug or device that they have a good faith belief is used for abortions.  In these instances, the pharmaceutical professional shall be immune from civil or criminal liability and will not have their license suspended or revoked.  Would provide that employers cannot refuse to hire, discriminate against, segregate, or terminate a pharmaceutical professional because of their opposition to any service involving a particular drug or device that they have a good faith belief is used for abortions.
(Filed and referred to committee 1/4/06; committee hearing conducted 2/13/06; did not pass by end of 2006 regular session)

NH
HB 1492
Rep. Hunter

Would grant immunity from liability to pharmacists who refuse to dispense an emergency contraceptive pill.
(Filed and referred to committee 1/4/06; public hearing set for 2/14/06; did not pass by end of 2006 regular session)

NH
SB 343
Sen. Letourneau

Would establish a pharmacist conscience clause which shields pharmacists refusing to fill emergency contraceptive prescriptions from civil liability and disciplinary action by the pharmacy board.
(Filed and referred to committee 1/4/06; did not pass by end of 2006 regular session)

NJ
AB 992
Rep. Stender
S 1195
Sen. Madden New item
Would prohibit pharmacists from refusing to dispense medication solely for philosophical, moral or religious reasons.
(AB 992 filed and referred to committee 1/10/06; added as a substitute to S 1195 10/19/06)
(S 1195 filed and referred to committee 1/30/06; passed Senate 31y-6n, 6/26/06; to Assembly 2nd reading 10/19/06)
(S 1195 passed Assembly 6/11/07; Approved P.L.2007, c.199 11/2/07)

NY
A 9536
Rep. Seminario
Would give complete and effective civil rights protection to health and human services workers who have conscientious objections to morally offensive medical procedures and policies, including pharmacists who provide contraception.
(Filed and referred to committee 1/17/06)

NY
S 1873
Sen. Maltese

Would allow any individual to refuse to provide assistance or information, or refuse to refer a person for such assistance or information, when providing a person with any form of assistance of information about contraception or contraceptive devices would be contrary to the conscience or religious beliefs of that individual; would prohibit discrimination by any public or private human services or health care agency, hospital, person, firm, corporation or association against the person so refusing to act.
(Filed and referred to committee 2/4/05; carried over from 2005 regular session; refiled and referred to committee 1/4/06)

NY
S 5994
Sen. Schneiderman

Would prohibit pharmacists from refusing to dispense medication solely for philosophical, moral, or religious reasons.
(Filed and referred to committee 10/12/05; carried over from 2005 regular session; reassigned to committee 1/4/06)

NY
S 7361
Sen. Duane
Would establish duties for pharmacies when pharmacists employed by such pharmacyrefuse to fill prescriptions on the basis of personal beliefs and would require a pharmacy to ensure the prescription is filled by another pharmacist.
(Filed and referred to committee 4/19/06)
NC
HB 1407
Rep. Barnhart

Would allow a pharmacist who states an objection to abortion on moral, ethical, or religious grounds, to refuse to prescribe or dispense drugs or devices that result in an abortion; such refusal would not be a basis for damages or for any disciplinary or any other recriminatory action against the pharmacist.
(Filed and referred to committee 4/20/05; carried over from 2005 regular session; did not pass by end of 2006 regular session)

OK
HB 2884
Rep. Steele
Would authorize a pharmacist's refusal to dispense medication.
(Filed and referred to committee 2/6/06; passed House 64y-34n, 3/14/06; did not pass Senate by end of 2006 regular session)

PA
HB 2311
Rep. Kirkland

Would make it illegal for any pharmacist to refuse to dispense or refill a prescription solely on the grounds that dispensing or refilling the prescription would contravene the pharmacist's philosophical, moral or religious beliefs.
(Filed and referred to committee 12/7/05; carried over from 2005 regular session)

PA
HB 2217
Rep. Frankel

Would establish certain duties for pharmacies when pharmacists employed by the pharmacies refuse to fill valid prescriptions for drugs or devices on the basis of personal beliefs.
(Filed and referred to committee 11/14/05; carried over from 2005 regular session)

PA
SB 1089
Sen. Williams
Would establish certain duties for pharmacies when pharmacists employed by the pharmacies refuse to fill valid prescriptions for drugs or devices on the basis of personal beliefs.
(Filed and referred to committee 3/16/06)

RI
HB 5085
Rep. Corvese

Would provide protection from discrimination to all health care providers who chose not to participate in a health care service that violates the conscience of the health care provider. The act would also provide a civil cause of action for damages in instances of violations of this act.
(Filed and referred to committee 1/13/05; carried over from 2005 regular session; did not pass by end of 2006 regular session)

RI
HB 6793
Rep. Corvese
SB 2804
Sen. Alves
Would provide protection from discrimination to all health care providers, including pharmacists, who choose not to participate in a health care service that violates the conscience of the health care provider.
(HB 6793 filed and referred to committee 1/17/06; SB 2804 filed and referred to committee 2/14/06; did not pass by end of 2006 regular session)
SD
HB 1184
Rep. Van Etten

Would allow health care providers, including pharmacists, and institutions to refuse to participate in certain health care services if those services violate the conscience of the health care provider; would provide protection from discrimination and administrative and civil liability.
(Filed and referred to committee 1/23/06; did not pass House 2/6/06; reconsideration failed 2/7/06)

TN
HB 1383
Rep. Casada

Concerns pharmacy and pharmacists; enacts the "Pharmacist's Freedom of Conscience Act."
(Filed and referred to committee 2/9/05; carried over from 2005 regular session; did not pass by end of 2006 regular session)
TN
SB 76
Sen. Finney
Concerns pharmacy and pharmacists; enacts the "Pharmacist's Freedom of Conscience Act."
(Filed and referred to committee 1/13/05; carried over from 2005 regular session; did not pass by end of 2006 regular session)
VT
HB 183
Rep. Donahue
Would respect and protect the fundamental rights of conscience of all individuals who provide health care services.
(Filed and referred to committee 2/8/05; carried over from 2005 regular session; did not pass by end of 2006 regular session)
WA
HB 1654
Rep. Ahern
Would ensure health care provider and insurer right of conscience.
(Filed and referred to committee 2/1/05; carried over from 2005 regular session and reintroduced 1/9/06; did not pass by end of 2006 regular session)
WA
SB 5851
Sen. Mulliken
Would ensure health care provider and insurer right of conscience.
(Filed and referred to committee 2/10/05; carried over from 2005 regular session and reintroduced 1/9/06; did not pass by end of 2006 regular session)
WV
HB 2042
Rep. Schoen
Would allow pharmacists and other individuals involved in dispensing medicines to refuse to fill prescriptions or dispense any substance that can be used as part of an abortion-related procedure.
(Filed and referred to committee 1/11/06; did not pass by end of 2006 regular session)
WV
HB 2807
Rep. Hatfield
Would prohibit pharmacists and other persons involved in dispensing medicines from refusing to fill prescriptions.
(Filed and referred to committee 1/11/06; did not pass by end of 2006 regular session)
WV
HB 3030
Rep. Houston

Would provide that health care providers (including pharmacists), health care institutions, or health care payers are not required to participate in abortion procedures that violate their respective consciences.
(Filed and referred to committee 1/11/06; did not pass by end of 2006 regular session)

WV 
HB 4449
Rep. Houston
SB 447
Sen. Sprouse

Would provide that health care providers (including pharmacists), health care institutions, or health care payers are not required to participate in abortion procedures that violate their respective consciences.
(Filed and referred to committee 2/7/06; did not pass by end of 2006 regular session)

WV 
HB 4644
Rep. Kiss

Would provide that pharmacists may exercise moral discretion without legal consequence to refuse to fill a prescription for "the morning after pill."
(Filed and referred to committee 2/20/06; did not pass by end of 2006 regular session)

WV
SB 29
Sen. Weeks
Would allow pharmacists and others to refuse to dispense abortion-related prescriptions.
(Filed and referred to committee 1/11/06; did not pass by end of 2006 regular session)

WV
SB 673
Sen. Barnes

Would give pharmacists the right to refuse to provide services.
(Filed and referred to committee 3/21/05; carried over from 2005 regular session; did not pass by end of 2006 regular session)

WI
AB 285
Rep. Owens

Would provide that a pharmacist's refusal to dispense a prescribed drug or device because he or she believes that the drug or device would be used for a purpose described above may not be the basis for a claim for damages against the pharmacist or the pharmacist's pharmacy.  Also, such a refusal may not be the basis for disciplinary action.
(Filed and referred to committee 4/4/05; carried over from 2005 regular session; did not pass by end of 2006 regular session)

WI
SB 155
Sen. Reynolds
Would relate to employment discrimination based on creed and exemption from liability and discipline for pharmacists who refuse to dispense for abortions, assisted suicides, and euthanasia; would provide that a pharmacist's refusal to dispense a prescribed drug or device because he or she believes that the drug or device would be used for a purpose described above may not be the basis for a claim for damages against the pharmacist or the pharmacist's pharmacy.
(Filed and referred to committee 4/1/05; carried over from 2005 regular session; did not pass by end of 2006 regular session)

 

2005 Legislation

 PHARMACIST REFUSAL CLAUSES

 REQUIRES A PHARMACIST TO FILL PRESCRIPTIONS

 GENERAL CONSCIENCE CLAUSES

PHARMACIST REFUSAL CLAUSES

AZ
HB 2541 (as amended)
Rep. Quelland

Would give pharmacists the right to refuse to provide emergency contraception.
(Filed and referred to committee 1/26/05; passed House 35y-24n, 2/28/05; passed Senate 17y-11n, 4/6/05; vetoed by governor 4/13/05)

AZ
SB 1485
Sen. Martin
Would allow pharmacists to refuse to provide contraception or emergency contraception based on moral or religious grounds.
(Filed and referred to committee 2/1/05; did not pass committee by end of 2005 regular session)
AR
SB 1141
Sen. Critcher
Would create the Arkansas health care rights of conscience act.
(Filed and referred to committee 3/7/05; did not pass committee by end of 2005 regular session)

GA
SB 123
Sen. Whitehead

Would provide that a pharmacist shall not be required to fill a precription for an emergency contraceptive drug; would provide that such refusal shall not be the basis for any claim for damages.
(Filed and referred to committee 2/7/05; carried over to 2006 regular session -- see 2006 bills above)

IN
SB 48
Sen. Drozda

Would allow a person to refuse to dispense artificial birth control.
(Filed and referred to committee 1/4/05; did not pass committee by end of 2005 regular session)

NC
HB 1407
Rep. Barnhart
Would allow a physician, nurse, pharmacist, or other health care provider who shall state an objection to abortion on moral, ethical, or religious grounds, to refuse to perform or participate in medical procedures or prescribe or dispense drugs or devices that result in an abortion.
(Filed and referred to committee 4/20/05; carried over to 2006 regular session -- see 2006 bills above)

RI
HB 5085
Rep. Corvese

Would give pharmacists the right to refuse to provide services.
(Filed and referred to committee 1/13/05; carried over to 2006 regular session -- see 2006 bills above)
SD
HB 1255
Rep. Van Etten

Would give pharmacists the right to refuse to provide services.
(Filed and referred to committee 2/1/05; did not pass committee by end of 2005 regular session)

TN
HB 1383
Rep. Casada

Would allow pharmacists to refuse to fill a particular prescription if it violates their religious or ethical principles.
(Filed and referred to committee 2/9/05; carried over to 2006 regular session -- see 2006 bills above)

TN
SB 76
Sen. Finney
Would allow pharmacists to refuse to fill a particular prescription if it violates their religious or ethical principles.
(Filed and referred to committee 1/13/05; carried over to 2006 regular session -- see 2006 bills above)

TX
HB 16
Rep. Corte

Would allow a pharmacist to refuse to participate in the distribution of emergency contraception.
(Filed and referred to committee 4/13/05; did not pass committee by end of 2005 regular session)

VT
HB 183
Rep. Donahue

Would establish a general conscience clause allowing providers the right to refuse to provide services.
(Filed and referred to committee 2/8/05; carried over to 2006 regular session -- see 2006 bills above)

WV
SB 673
Sen. Barnes

Would give pharmacists the right to refuse to provide services.
(Filed and referred to committee 3/21/05; carried over to 2006 regular session -- see 2006 bills above)

WI 
AB 207
Rep. Hundertmark
Would allow pharmacists to refuse to exempt based on religious or moral grounds.
(Filed and referred to committee 3/14/05; vetoed by governor 10/14/05)
WI
SB 155
Sen. Reynolds
Would relate to employment discrimination based on creed and exemption from liability and discipline for pharmacists who refuse to dispense for abortions, assisted suicides, and euthanasia; would provide that a pharmacist's refusal to dispense a prescribed drug or device because he or she believes that the drug or device would be used for a purpose described above may not be the basis for a claim for damages against the pharmacist or the pharmacist's pharmacy.
(Filed and referred to committee 4/1/05; carried over to 2006 regular session -- see 2006 bills above)

 

REQUIRES A PHARMACIST TO FILL PRESCRIPTIONS

CA
AB 21
Rep. Levine

Would require a pharmacist to dispense a prescription except in specified circumstances; would allow a pharmacist to decline on ethical, moral, or religious grounds to dispense a drug pursuant to a lawful request only if he or she satisfies certain conditions and would make a violation of these provisions unprofessional conduct, subject to disciplinary action by the Board of Pharmacy.
(Filed and referred to committee 12/7/04; did not pass committee by end of 2005 regular session)

CA
SB 644
Sen. Ortiz
Would require that health care professionals dispense prescription drugs and devices in a timely way or provide appropriate referrals for patients to obtain the necessary prescription drugs and devices, despite the health care professional's objection to dispensing the drugs or devices on ethical, moral, or religious grounds.
(Filed and referred to committee 2/22/05; signed into law by governor 9/29/05, as Chapter 417

MO
SB 458
Sen. Wheeler

Would require pharmacists to fill prescriptions against religious beliefs unless an employer can accommodate a request not to do so.
(Filed and referred to committee 2/28/05; did not pass committee by end of 2005 regular session)

NJ
AB 3772 
Assm. Stender

Would prohibit pharmacists from refusing to dispense medication solely for philosophical, moral or religious reasons.
(Filed and referred to committee 2/7/05; did not pass committee by end of 2005 regular session)

 

NJ
SB 2178
Sen. Madden
Would prohibit pharmacists from refusing to dispense medication solely for philosophical, moral or religious reasons.
(Filed and referred to committee 1/11/05; did not pass committee by end of 2005 regular session)

WV
HB 2807
Rep. Hatfield

Would prohibit pharmacists and other persons involved in dispensing medicines from refusing to fill prescriptions.
(Filed and referred to committee 3/1/05; carried over to 2006 regular session -- see 2006 bills above)

 

GENERAL CONSCIENCE CLAUSES

MD
SB 541
Sen. Grosfeld

Would establish the Emergency Contraception Dispensing Program in the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene (DHMH); would provide a means of authorizing specified licensed pharmacists to dispense emergency contraception without a prescription in accordance with specified procedures.
(Filed and referred to committee 2/4/05; did not pass by end of 2005 regular session)

MI
HB 4741
Rep. Palmer

Would provide standards for personnel policies to protect and accommodate the right of conscience of health care providers who conscientiously object to providing or participating in certain health care services under certain circumstances; would provide for protection from certain liability; would provide for penalties and remedies.
(Filed and referred to committee 5/5/05; carried over to 2006 regular session -- see 2006 bills above)

TX
HB 2061
Rep. Laubenberg
SB 1016
Sen. Deuell

Would broadly allow providers to not provide services.  Bills do not specifically include pharmacists as providers, but the bill includes “dispensing” as an activity under participate, so the bills may include pharmacists.
(Filed and referred to committee 3/4/05; did not pass committee by end of 2005 regular session)

Sources: National Conference of State Legislatures; Denver, Colorado.

Compiled by NCSL Health Program, Denver.

Note: List may not be comprehensive, but is representative of state laws that exist. NCSL appreciates additions and corrections.

Denver Office: Tel: 303-364-7700 | Fax: 303-364-7800 | 7700 East First Place | Denver, CO 80230 | Map
Washington Office: Tel: 202-624-5400 | Fax: 202-737-1069 | 444 North Capitol Street, N.W., Suite 515 | Washington, D.C. 20001