Ethics Committees and Ethics Commissions: What's the Difference?
|
Ethics Committees |
Ethics Commissions |
|
Members are state Legislators |
Members are citizens or public officials appointed by governor or other leaders. Twenty-four states forbid public officials from serving on ethics commissions. |
|
Internal oversight. Committee members oversee their peers compliance with ethics laws. |
External oversight. Commission members oversee state employees and legislators compliance with ethics laws. |
|
Legislative branch; Can be a joint committee, or each chamber within the legislature can have its own. |
Most are part of the executive branch, although their budgets, in most states, are controlled by the Legislature. |
|
Duties can include:
- Consider their colleagues' violations of ethics statutes
- Administering state ethics laws in states without committees
- Authoring chambers codes of ethics.
|
Duties can include:
- adopting regulations pertaining to state's ethics laws, providing ethics training,
- investigating ethics complaints and determining penalties or issuing advisory opinions
- Receiving financial disclosure and lobbyist reporting statements.
|
|
Jurisdiction includes only the legislature. |
Jurisdiction sometimes includes the legislature, often includes other branches of state government. |
|
Present in some form in all 50 states. |
Present in some form in 39 states, having jurisdiction over the legislative branch in 33. (Commissions in Illinois, Indiana, New York, Michigan, Ohio, and North Carolina do not have authority over legislators.) |
Center for Ethics in Government main
|