|
|
Home | Contact Us | Press Room | Site Overview | Help | Login | Register |
![]() |
![]() |
| About NCSL | State & Federal Issues | Legislatures | Legislative Staff | Meetings | Bookstore | Legislators & Staff Only |
| NCSL Home > State & Federal Issues: Issue Areas > Environmental Protection > Air Quality > | Add to MyNCSL |
Environment, Energy and Transportation ProgramClean Air NewsletterA Quarterly Review of Mobile and Stationary Source Issues
November, 2001IN THIS ISSUE FEDERAL ACTION EPA Developing 8-Hour Ozone Standard Strategy TRIBAL ACTION Tribes' Standards Setting Rights Affirmed STATE ACTIONS Texas Emissions Reduction Plan STATE LEGISLATION 2001 State Air Quality Legislation
FEDERAL ACTIONEPA Developing 8-Hour Ozone Standard StrategyThe U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has begun discussions with governmental stakeholder groups on the best ways to begin transitioning from the 1-hour ozone standard to the 8-hour ozone standard. The agency's action is being taken pursuant to a February 27 U.S. Supreme Court decision upholding the agency's authority to issue the new standard, but requiring the agency to reconsider its implementation plan (see March 2001 Clean Air Newsletter for article on court decision). EPA began the discussions with a conference call on October 10 involving eight governmental stakeholder groups, including the National Conference of State Legislatures. Other groups invited to participate were the National Governors Association, the National League of Cities, the U.S. Conference of Mayors, the Environmental Council of the States, the National Association of Regional Councils, the National Association of Counties, and the State and Territorial Air Pollution Program Administrators/Association of Local Air Pollution Control Officials. EPA is considering two different frameworks within which to make the transition from the 1-hour ozone standard to the new 8-hour standard. Under a two-standard approach, the agency could require areas to attain the 1-hour standard first and then prepare a new plan to attain compliance with the 8-hour standard. Under a one-standard approach, EPA could require areas to comply with the 8-hour standard only, revoking the one-hour standard in the short term. EPA plans to issue a draft rule on the implementation process during the spring of 2002. The final rule would be promulgated one year later. The agency does not anticipate designating nonattainment areas under the 8-hour standard until after the new rule becomes final. EPA Releases New Report on Status of Air QualityThe U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) released a report in September updating the status of the nation's air quality. Latest Findings on National Air Quality: 2000 Status and Trends notes that since 1970, aggregate emissions (as measured in tons) of six primary pollutants-carbon monoxide (CO), nitrogen oxides (NOx), volatile organic compounds (VOC), sulfur dioxide (SO2), particulate matter (PM) and lead (Pb)-decreased by 29 percent. Ground-level ozone, formed by VOC and NOx, provided the greatest challenge, with levels increasing in the north central and southern regions of the United States and in 29 national parks. NOx emissions contributed most heavily to the worsening ozone levels, increasing by nearly 20 percent during this period. Conversely, SO2 emissions-which are largely responsible for acid rain-declined from 16 million tons in 1990 to 11 million tons in 2000. The percentage decrease or increase in emissions from 1970 to 2000 for each of the primary pollutants appears in table 1. The full report can be viewed on the agency's Web site at www.epa.gov/airtrends. EPA Releases New Green Vehicle GuideThe U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) released on October 9 its Green Vehicle Guide of model year 2002 emissions data. The guide " ... rates vehicles according to their environmental performance and includes both emission and fuel economy information." It allows customers to compare vehicles be category. Four vehicles in three categories received the highest score-10: Two Seater-Honda Insight (hybrid electric) Compact Car-Toyota Prius (hybrid electric) and Nissan Sentra Midsize Car-Honda Accord The highest ranking of any vehicle by other category of vehicle is as follows:
The full report can be viewed on the agency's Web site at www.epa.gov/greenvehicles. DOE: Greenhouse Gas Emissions RisingThe U.S. Department of Energy's (DOE) Energy Information Administration (EIA) released a report in November that found a 2.5 percent increase in greenhouse gas emissions in the United States from 1999 to 2000. Emission of Greenhouse Gases in the United States 2000 determined that emissions totaled 1,906 million metric tons of carbon equivalent in 2000, compared to 1,860 million metric tons in 1999. This figure was nearly double the average annual growth rate for the decade. EIA concluded that the rise in emissions was due to colder winter temperatures, a decrease in hydroelectric power generation due to the drought (which was replaced by fossil fuels that emit more carbon dioxide), and strong economic growth (a 4.1 percent increase in the gross domestic product). Emissions of carbon dioxide (CO2) from fossil fuel combustion-coal, petroleum and natural gas-accounted for 81.2 percent of the greenhouse total. CO2 emissions were 3.1 percent higher in 2000 than in 1999. The residential/commercial sector accounted for the largest percentage increase at 5.3 percent over the previous year. Emissions from electric power generation rose 4.7 percent, and transportation sector CO2 emissions grew by 3.1 percent. Industrial emissions remained flat. In addition to carbon dioxide, methane accounted for the second largest total of greenhouse gas emissions-9.3 percent-and nitrous oxide emissions weighed in at 5.3 percent. The full report can be viewed at www.eia.doe.gov/index/html. NOAA, NASA: "Ozone Hole" StabilizingIn a study released October 16, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) and NASA, the nation's space agency, reported that the ozone hole over the Antarctic had peaked at about 10 million square miles. This level is similar in size to the depletion in the earth's atmosphere over the Arctic and roughly the same as documented during the past three years. The report noted that, "This is consistent with human-produced chlorine compounds that destroy [high-level, as opposed to ground-level] ozone reaching their peak concentrations in the atmosphere, leveling off, and now beginning a very slow decline." Scientists with both federal agencies anticipate that during the next 30 to 50 years the severity of the ozone hole over Antarctica should diminish as chlorine levels show a comparable decline. The full report can be viewed on NOAA's Web site at www.noaanews.noaa.gov/stories/s792.htm. TRIBAL ACTIONTribes' Standards Setting Rights AffirmedIn April 2001, the U.S. Supreme Court let stand a U.S. District of Columbia Circuit Court of Appeals ruling that upheld the right of Indian tribes to regulate air quality on all land within reservations, including fee land held by non-tribal owners. That court had also upheld the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency's interpretation of reservation to include trust land and pueblos. Based on an interpretation of the statutory language and history, the court of appeals disagreed with industry groups and the state of Michigan that Congress did not expressly delegate authority to tribes to regulate air quality on all reservation land including fee land owned by non-Indians, trust land and pueblos. Tribal authority to regulate air quality is not a recent phenomenon. The 1977 amendments to the Clean Air Act gave tribes authority to redesignate land as class I, II or III for purposes of setting air quality standards (42 U.S.C. §7474(c)). Under the 1990 Clean Air Act Amendments, tribes were given authority by Congress to submit tribal implementation plans for areas within the exterior boundaries of the reservation (42 U.S.C. §7410(o)). Furthermore, the Clean Air Act Amendments state that tribes will be treated as states for purposes of delegating authority to regulate air quality for " ... air resources within the exterior boundaries of the reservation or other areas within the tribe's jurisdiction (42 U.S.C. §7601(d)(2)(B))." To implement that provision, the Tribal Authority Rule passed in 1998 allows tribes to be treated as states for virtually all Clean Air Act programs, including the operating permit program. STATE ACTIONSTexas Emissions Reduction PlanTexas currently has 16 counties that are classified as nonattainment areas for one or more "criteria pollutants," and many more that are approaching that classification. In response, the Texas Legislature created the Texas Emissions Reduction Plan, effective Sept. 1, 2001, to provide incentives to lower emissions that impede the state from attaining federal air quality standards (see State Legislation section of this newsletter). Sponsored by Senator J.E. "Buster" Brown, the chairman of the Senate Natural Resources Committee, the seven-year program will use increased consumer and business fees to provide incentives to consumers and businesses to purchase cleaner-burning and more energy-efficient products. To pay for the new programs, the Texas Emissions Reduction Plan Fund has been established. The fund will consist of money collected from increased registration fees for commercial vehicles, fees for the sale or lease of construction equipment and large on-road diesel vehicles, fees for all vehicles registering for the first time in Texas, and fees for commercial vehicle inspections. It is estimated that more than $150 million will be collected during the next five years. The majority of the funds will go to the diesel reduction incentive plan, which includes grants for several eligible actions, including: • Purchasing or leasing non-road diesel vehicles such as construction equipment; • Retrofitting and replacement of diesel engines to reduce emissions; • Developing and demonstrating technologies for lowering diesel engine emissions; • Using alternative fuels; and • Infrastructure projects. Other components of the plan include an on-road diesel vehicle purchase incentive program that would apply to vehicles such as delivery trucks, school buses and garbage trucks, as well as incentives for certain automobile purchases. Tax exemptions are provided for certain low-emission diesel fuel, and an energy efficiency grant program would target projects that replace building materials and appliances that "contribute to peak energy demand." The new law also creates the Texas Council on Environmental Technology to administer grants to promote emissions-reducing technologies. Research projects that deal with reduction of state vehicle emissions, low-emission vehicles, air quality modeling, and building and appliance energy efficiency are eligible for these grants. Finally, the law adopts the energy efficiency chapter of the International Residential Code as the energy code for single-family homes. MTBE Waiver ConsiderationsSince the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) denied California's request on June 12 to waive the federal Clean Air Act's (CAA) requirement that reformulated gasoline (RFG) continue to utilize oxygen additives (see July 2001 Clean Air Newsletter article on waiver denial), New York, New Hampshire and other northeastern states have begun to consider requesting waivers. Of primary concern to the states is methyl tertiary butyl ether (MTBE), which is used to oxygenate gasoline. This ether oxygenate delivers high octane levels at a relatively low cost and meets the CAA's 2-percent oxygen requirement. MTBE provides for more efficient and complete burning of fuel, which reduces carbon monoxide (CO) emissions. Many states have passed legislation to ban or phase out the use of MTBE as a fuel additive because of possible health risks (see State Legislation section of this newsletter). Due to leaks from underground gasoline storage tanks and pipelines, MTBE is seeping out and contaminating ground and drinking water supplies. MTBE readily dissolves in water, moves rapidly through aquifers and soil, is resistant to microbial breakdown and decay, and is difficult to remove through water purification processes. EPA has classified MTBE as a potential human carcinogen, but has not established a drinking water standard. The California Department of Health Services, however, has set a standard. Despite the ruling against California, New York's Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC) believes that oxygenates no longer are necessary in gasoline because engine technology has advanced and engines are being manufactured to burn cleaner and produce fewer emissions. New York's potential application for a waiver would focus on the EPA's approval of computer modeling of vehicle engines that produce fewer emissions. DEC has not decided, however, when or if it will file a request. The state currently is working in Congress to support legislation to repeal the oxygenate requirement. If these efforts fail, New York will consider how to progress with the petition waiver. Other northeastern states also are considering requests to waive the oxygenated fuel requirement and support elimination of the oxygen mandate. Justifications that officials may use in their waiver petitions include a recent report (see below) recommending a thorough study of the use of ethanol instead of MTBE and an analysis of its effect on the environment; additional testing to measure potential increases in emissions from the use of ethanol in non-road vehicles, such as lawn and garden equipment; data on evaporative emissions that auto makers recently have developed and that was not previously available for California to use in its petition; and further analysis of the effects of mixing ethanol and non-ethanol fuels if MTBE is phased out in the region. New Hampshire had voluntarily entered into the RFG program but now is trying to leave the program (see State Legislation section in this newsletter). EPA will not allow the state to leave the program unless it has its own gasoline rule in place. The Department of Environmental Services (DES) has adopted a rule, conditionally approved by the Joint Legislative Committee on Administrative Rules on October 19, that would create a new fuel-oxyfree reformulated gasoline (OFRFG)-that would meet federal standards but would not contain oxygenates. The state wants to end the use of MTBE and does not want to replace it with ethanol-an alcohol oxygenate derived from corn-because it would have to be imported and raises other air quality concerns. New Hampshire has endorsed the findings of a report written by the Northeast States for Coordinated Air Use Management and the New England Interstate Water Pollution Control Commission-Health, Environmental and Economic Impacts of Adding Ethanol to Gasoline in the Northeast States-that calls for further studies of ethanol to determine its effects on human health. Court Upholds California Fleet RulesA federal court has upheld fleet rules proposed by the South Coast Air Quality Management District (SCAQMD), the air pollution control agency for Orange County, California. In 1987, the California Legislature adopted a Health and Safety Code that authorized SCAQMD to adopt fleet rules in an effort to reduce public exposure to motor vehicle pollution. The rules require city, state and other public agencies in the greater Los Angeles area to make a gradual transition and begin purchasing or leasing low-emission or alternative-fuel vehicles for their fleets. When a fleet is replacing or adding vehicles, it is required to purchase an alternative-fuel vehicle in order to phase out the older, higher polluting models. These vehicles include public transit and school buses, garbage trucks, public works vehicles, airport shuttles and street sweepers. The rules most recently took effect on July 1, 2001; additional rules are scheduled for July 1, 2002. The Engine Manufacturers Association challenged the rules. This trade association represents the leading manufacturers of internal combustion engines used in most heavy- and medium-duty vehicles, not including passenger cars. It claimed that the Clean Air Act (CAA) preempts SCAQMD from imposing the requirements, and that they constitute local vehicle emissions standards prohibited under the CAA. U.S. District Judge Florence-Marie Cooper disagreed and wrote that the fleet rules " ... regulate the purchasing and leasing of vehicles by fleet operators ... The rules impose no new emissions requirements on manufacturers whatsoever, and therefore do not run afoul of Congress' purpose behind motor vehicle preemption: namely the protection of manufacturers against having to build engines in compliance with a multiplicity of standards." The court concluded that " ... the fleet rules were not preempted by ... the Clean Air Act and are a valid exercise of SCAQMD's authority."
STATE LEGISLATIONAs initially reported in the July 2001 Clean Air Newsletter, the 2001 state legislative sessions have seen significant activity in air quality legislation. Much of it has been related to the concerns over energy supply and the air quality effects of accelerated electricity generation. The California Legislature, for example, passed legislation requiring the State Air Resources Board to establish a schedule for retrofitting electric generating facilities and implementing an emissions trading program for power plants (SBX1 28). Illinois enacted legislation that requires the Illinois Environmental Protection Agency to report findings to the legislature and authorizes it to propose rules to reduce nitrogen oxide, sulfur dioxide and mercury emissions, and provide voluntary incentives to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from fossil fuel-fired electric generating plants (SB 372). Montana passed legislation that would enable small, temporary power plants to operate without an air quality permit provided they do not violate ambient air quality standards (SB 398). Oklahoma enacted a law that provides tax credits for the generation of electricity from zero-emission facilities (SB 440). Although the legislation was vetoed by the governor, the Connecticut General Assembly passed legislation that would have placed a sulfur dioxide emissions cap on older, high-polluting facilities and authorized the cap to be suspended during electricity shortages (SHB 6365). Incentives for alternative fuel vehicles also captured significant legislative attention. Georgia expanded its tax credit program for the purchase of low-emission vehicles to include a higher credit for the purchase of a zero-emission vehicle (HB 261). Hawaii adjusted its fuel tax by reducing the rate assessed on alternative fuels (HB 1345). Oklahoma extended its income tax credit for investment in clean burning fuel property (HB 1219). The Illinois General Assembly is close to passing a measure that would extend the conversion cost rebate program for vehicles that run on alternative fuels and would create an Alternative Fuel Infrastructure Program to award grants to construct alternative fueling facilities (HB 2). The single issue garnering the most legislative interest has been methyl tertiary butyl ether (MTBE). Five states-Illinois, Kansas, New Hampshire, South Dakota and Washington-have enacted legislation to phase out the use of MTBE as a gasoline additive in reformulated gasoline (see related story on EPA's denial of California's request for a waiver of the oxygenate requirement and actions being considered by northeastern states in this newsletter). The details are contained in the following tables, which summarize bills either enacted or being close to passage during the 2001 sessions. To download copies of the legislation cited, log on to NCSL's Web site at www.ncsl.org, and go to Internet Sites of State Legislatures. Summaries of Selected 2001 Bills
|
© 2008 National Conference of State Legislatures, All Rights Reserved
Denver Office: Tel: 303-364-7700 | Fax: 303-364-7800 | 7700 East First Place | Denver, CO 80230 | Map
Washington Office: Tel: 202-624-5400 | Fax: 202-737-1069 | 444 North Capitol Street, N.W., Suite 515 | Washington, D.C. 20001